The Fairy Tale Fix: How to Unstick Your Story


Hi Reader,

Do you ever come up with a big idea but find yourself stuck figuring out the story around it? You’ve got the world, but where are the characters? Or maybe you have an amazing protagonist, but no conflict to throw them into. Don’t worry; you’re not alone. Every storyteller hits this roadblock. My favorite way to power through it? A little something I call the Fairy Tale Fix.

The Magic of Once Upon a Time

In the enchanting land of fairy tales, every story starts with these classic words: Once upon a time...

Here’s how it works: You take your big idea—whether it’s a setting, a character, or a premise—and treat it like the start of a fairy tale.

If you’ve got your setting as your shiny idea:

Once upon a time, there was a kingdom where dancing was outlawed.

See? We’ve already got intrigue. Now, who’s going to challenge that rule? Your story is on its way!

If your big idea is a character:

Once upon a time, there was a girl who loved to dance...

Boom! Instant protagonist. Now, what’s going to get in her way? Ah-ha! That kingdom where dancing is outlawed. See how the setting and character naturally flow into each other?

The beauty of this technique is that it leads you effortlessly from setting to character, from character to conflict, and from conflict to villain. Before you know it, you’ve got a one-page story that lays out the bones of your plot, complete with all three acts.

Simple, Yet Powerful

But wait, there’s more! (I told you this was magic.) The Fairy Tale Fix works even if you already have a full story but feel stuck and tangled in a web of too much stuff. You know the feeling—your plot is full of holes, the stakes feel muddy, and your characters are wandering around lost.

The thing about fairy tales? They’ve lasted for hundreds of years because they’re simple and memorable. They have just enough story. And they don’t waste time with anything extra. So, when your plot is too complicated, it’s time to trim it down.

Here’s how: Write your story as if it were a fairy tale. Yep, start with Once upon a time… and let the simplicity guide you back to the heart of your story. No frills, no fancy subplots—just the essence of what you’re trying to say.

It’s a magical way to remind yourself what your story is truly about, and to rediscover the clarity and simplicity that made you love your idea in the first place. Try it, and you might just say, “Happily ever after” to your writer’s block!


My Current Obsession

My Current Obsession is on hiatus this week because it turned into a full-blown newsletter. So stay tuned to see what has got me so excited!


In Case You Missed It

How to Write a Biopic

Write a Review and Help an Author

Lean into What's Working

Cheers,

Lindsey

Thanks for reading!

You can share this article HERE

Was this week's newsletter useful? Help me to improve!

Click on a link to vote:

👍Super! - 😐 Meh - 👎 Not my jam

Hi I'm Lindsey Hughes

Hi, I’m Lindsey. I love helping people discover their superpower, create compelling content, and feel excited about pitching and networking. I teach people how to pitch like a boss, network like a VIP, and write like an Oscar winner. Subscribe to my weekly newsletter for actionable creativity and career tips.

Read more from Hi I'm Lindsey Hughes
story momentum equals cause and effect

The Pitch Master Newsletter Cause and Effect: The Story Chain Reaction A story is not just a string of things that happen. A story is a chain reaction. This happens, therefore that happens. A character makes a choice, therefore something changes. A secret is revealed, therefore a relationship blows up. A plan fails, therefore the hero has to try something riskier, scarier, or stupider. That is cause and effect. And when it is working, your story feels inevitable. It pulls the reader or viewer...

The Pitch Master Newsletter The World’s Largest Library Is Hiding in Plain Sight (And Your Books and Screenplays Should Be In It) Imagine a library 100 times larger than the Library of Alexandria. A library with millions of books in every language, stretching back centuries. A library where a reader can search almost any topic and instantly discover a book about it. Cool! That library exists. It’s called Google Books. And if you’re an author or screenwriter, it may be one of the most powerful...

plot hole

The Pitch Master Newsletter Nothing yanks me out of a story faster than a plot hole. If they’re really stupid, I get mad. And I quit reading or watching. That disconnect doesn’t just “break immersion”, it breaks trust, and it quietly murders your relationship with your reader/viewer. Plot holes can happen anywhere, but they’re most common in mysteries, thrillers, and action stories, where the engine of the story is cause-and-effect. At their core, plot holes are logic problems with motives,...